
Yes, according to the law, if you are a tax resident of Mexico and you earn money in Mexico, you have to pay income tax on that money.
Many people ask about taxation and this can be a very touchy or a very vague issue. Generally speaking, all countries want people to pay taxes from income that is sourced from that country. So someone earning money in Mexico should pay taxes into Mexico on those earnings. It gets a little muddy if someone is working over the Internet in Mexico and gets paid from the US. Right now, other than the US, countries don’t seem to be demanding payment of taxes that were earned in other countries. The issue is vague. The US wants to tax you on worldwide income. However, if you are a US taxpayer with earned income in Mexico and you’re living here in Mexico and your time in the US is very minimal, then you can apply for an exemption of earned income up to about US $100,000 on your US taxes.
For example, let’s say I live here in Mexico. I can work as an attorney and make roughly $100,000 tax-free of US income tax, so I am not double taxed. If I’ve been in Mexico and haven’t been in the US more than 1 month out of a year, Mexico will tax my earnings here and the Mexican tax rate is higher. I pay from my professional services a 16% sales tax and VAT or IVA, tax plus I pay income tax.
A lot of times people who have investment accounts in Mexico with brokerage houses are paying their earned interest and there’s a withholding on those funds. Those accounts should be declared to the US government under a host of different laws. There’s a $10,000 threshold, there is a $50,000 threshold for the foreign bank account. They can declare the interest or dividends they make but the Mexican withholding rate is generally higher so they can apply the foreign tax credit. In all circumstances, however, the taxpayer still has their reporting requirement.
As another example, if you are an American citizen and in Mexico long enough to become a tax resident of Mexico and you earn money is for work that you did for people who are outside of Mexico, perhaps for IT support for people in the US, Mexico will probably want you to pay tax on the money you earned. However, the current practice that we have seen is they are not enforcing it. If Mexico sees that the income is from a source outside of Mexico and you’re paying taxes in other country with that money, then up to now they haven’t been going after people for the payment of that tax. A strict application of the law, irrespective of whether it’s enforced, is if you are a tax resident of Mexico, you must pay taxes on any income earned, irrespective of source, anywhere in the world.
Part of the reason this hasn’t been enforced by Mexico is that they don’t have much of a way of knowing when people have living in one jurisdiction, earning money from another jurisdiction, and maybe that jurisdiction isn’t necessarily collecting taxes on that income.
In my personal situation, I am a tax resident of Mexico, and I pay Mexican taxes on money sourced from Mexico. I have an SC, which is like a professional corporation. I have to do a monthly and annual tax filing in which I have to declare and pay and withhold income tax and sales tax on my services. In addition, I declare in the US the money that I made here but it’s not taxed because I use the Foreign Earned Income Exemption.
I advise all people to comply with the tax laws and get advice from a competent accountant. In Mexico, I’ve seen people fined 3,000, 6,000, 10,000 pesos for not filing a return even when their tax liability is zero. One way people could get caught is if they’re paid in the US and they withdraw their money at ATMs, the tax agency here in Mexico has been sending invitation letters to people who were depositing more than 15,000 cash in their account saying “You owe taxes on those are undeclared earnings and you need to prove where those earnings are coming from.” We’ve done this for some clients and the Mexican government has said, “Okay, no problem.” Others they have required an insurmountable amount of documentation to prove the deposits weren’t income. People who earn in the US and withdraw from their ATMs in Mexico and depositing in Mexican bank accounts could be on the Mexican tax agency’s radar.
I haven’t seen anyone prosecuted for failure to pay Mexican taxes who was living in Mexico as a tax resident who didn’t declare the money they received from the US, but I’m not a tax law specialist, even though I’m in a place where there’s lots of foreigners and usually things that come across might be asked in the classes I take. My classmates are tax experts and none of them have reported this type of thing happening to foreigners. As of now, it’s not been an issue due to the difficulty for the tax agency to verify and prove non-compliance, but it is possible.
A lot of people feel that if they come back and forth every six months on a tourist visa that they will not be a resident for tax purposes in Mexico. Others may say, “I don’t want to be a permanent resident in Mexico. I’m a snowbird. I might live here 3 months a year.” People need to remember it is their center of life, their center of interest, their source of income and the time they spent in a country that’s going to dictate whether they’re a tax resident or not, as opposed to the name of their immigration document.
(Golf course at Loreto Bay, Baja California, Mexico, pictured.)